January 17, 2025
In today’s complex health care environment, managing pharmacy benefits is a critical task for plan sponsors, CHROs, CFOs and Total Reward leaders. Pharmacy Benefit Managers (PBMs) play a pivotal role in this process, helping to control expenses and ensure that employees receive the medications they need.
This article aims to provide you with a comprehensive understanding of the key areas to focus on when working with PBMs. By gaining insights into contract terms, specialty medications, formulary management, flexibility, additional programming and financial integrity management, you can make informed decisions that align with your organization’s goals and fiduciary responsibilities. Our goal is to equip you with the knowledge and tools necessary to navigate this intricate landscape effectively.
The world of pharmacy benefits is complex, with many moving parts and pieces. Pharmacy Benefit Managers (PBMs) are tools for administering and managing pharmacy benefits, putting the puzzle pieces together. Plan sponsors must ensure they understand how their PBM, or future PBM, partner works in their best interest. Here are six areas of focus within your PBM that you need to understand.
1. Contract
Your contract with your PBM is arguably the most critical aspect of your relationship. It defines how you are set up for success. One term or one condition can make the difference between large costs and impactful savings.
Questions to ask:
- What pricing model are you under? Is it a traditional (spread) pricing model or a transparent pass-through model?
- Does your contract have minimum guarantees for pricing components and rebates?
- Can claim exclusions be defined by national databases or resources?
2. Specialty Medications
The cost of specialty medications can easily reach 50% of your total pharmacy cost, often for only a handful of drugs. Many of these expensive, impactful medications are now available in generic or biosimilar form, but that does not always lead to savings. Not only can it leave money on the table, but the high cost of these agents at certain PBMs and pharmacies has been the focal point of recent lawsuits brought against employers related to their fiduciary responsibilities.
Questions to ask:
- Are specialty guarantees broken down into brand and generic/biosimilar?
- What is the pricing of common generic specialty medications available for less at cost-plus pharmacy options?
- What is the PBM’s formulary strategy on biosimilars?
- What is the PBM’s new-to-market strategy?
3. Formulary Management and Prior Authorizations
Formulary management is a large, encompassing concept of how your PBM makes decisions and designs benefits. Like contracts, decisions and design in this area can impact overall results. Prior authorizations (PAs) are necessary to ensure the proper use of safe and effective medications. When it comes to formulary management and PAs, the PBM makes multiple decisions throughout the process. PBMs are not required to ensure that decisions made in this area are in the best interest of their clients.
Questions to ask:
- What formulary are you currently on? Is it open or closed/exclusive?
- How aggressive is your current formulary, and how does it align with your goals?
- What is the average generic dispensing rate for the PBM’s book of business, and what is your specific plan sponsor rate?
- What is the PBM’s PA approval rate for specialty and non-specialty medications?
4. Flexibility
While the PBM is a tool for your plan’s pharmacy benefits, there is often value in customizing their offerings to fit your unique needs. Not all PBMs allow customization or offer the level of customization needed. When optimization can lead to savings, it is vital to have a PBM that can work to deploy your customizations.
Questions to ask:
- Do you have the ability to provide custom adjustments to your PBM offerings beyond plan design decisions?
- Can the PBM code and operationalize custom exclusion lists?
- Can the PBM administer custom PA criteria?
- Can the PBM model and provide information on how customizations may impact your rebates?
5. Additional Programming
PBMs offer many programs that clients can opt in or out of. These programs can promise cost savings that are not always realized. Understanding and evaluating your current programs is essential, but it is also critical to regularly address and evaluate additional offerings, as they are constantly changing.
Questions to ask:
- What programming do you currently have turned on, what is the cost, and what outcomes are you achieving?
- Are there additional PBM-provided programs available to opt in to? What do they cost, and what type of return on investment should you expect?
- Do you currently have a co-pay assistance program? Is it for specialty medications only or specialty and brand-name medications?
6. Contract and Financial Integrity Management
A tight contract, strong formulary management, flexible offerings and additional programming selections are all important to success. As a plan sponsor, it is vital to monitor that success and hold PBMs accountable. At the same time, a strong contract can age quickly in this changing environment. Waiting three years for financial updates is a surefire way to leave money on the table.
Questions to ask:
- Do you have the ability to complete market checks to keep your contract fresh?
- Do you have operational performance guarantees? What are they, how are they measured, and how has the PBM performed?
- Do you have the contractual right to reconcile financial performance at the end of every contract year?
Understanding these areas of focus within your PBM can help ensure your plan achieves your overall goals as a plan sponsor. Even with the answers to these questions, there is still a lot to unpack in the world of PBMs, which is why working with a pharmacy benefit consulting partner can be beneficial. Unfortunately, some consultants can add to the lack of transparency if they are not transparent themselves. That is why Innovative Rx Strategies is PBM-agnostic, does not run any coalitions and doesn’t take money from anyone in the supply chain. If you want to learn more about how we can support you, contact us today.
